I wanted to clarify a few things because I was definitely responding
too quickly yesterday, so my apologies!
First, I had no idea those Red Hat repos for GitHub Actions existed already
on GitHub. We're a big company with a lot of smart motivated people, with a
lot of different opinions, so it can be difficult to track all of the work
that "we" (the greater community as well as just internal Red Hat people)
Since somebody already built those GitHub Actions (I'm not sure who), I see
no reason not to use them. At some point, I'd love to get RHEL out as a
runner and then convert them over, but I see no reason to "not use Ubuntu"
as Podman is a community project and people seem like they may already be
Being super honest, I read your email too quickly yesterday and I thought
you were a Red Hat person asking for Red Hat engineering and product
management about this! It happens all the time, and you may have detected a
bit of frustrationin my response, or at a minimum terseness. I apologize
The confusing thing for me is, I would have thought the Communtiy repos (
) would provide GitHub Actions code for Ubuntu
runners, while one might expect the Red Hat repos to have ones for RHEL
runners. Or in a perfect world, the community ones would support both an
Ubuntu runner and a RHEL runner (if I can get one created).
Either way, it's definitely confusing. I'll try to hunt down whoever
created the Red Hat ones and talk about moving them into the community. I
think you are right, this is where I would expect to find them as well. Let
me redefine my what I'd like to see in a perfect world:
1. Get rid of repos in Red Hat repo (but, I don't want to remove them if
that would break people)
2. Have upstream GitHub Actions in the /containers repos (support Ubuntu
runners today, maybe support both RHEL as well someday)
3. Have a downstream, productized Actions code which uses RHEL exclusively
(maybe supports custom UBI runners, RHEL VM runners, and a potential RHEL
instance on GitHub in the future). This might live back in the Red Hat repo
or somewhere else, I'm not sure.
Well, sorry for the weird interaction and confusion. I hope this helps.
On Thu, May 26, 2022, 5:13 PM Craig Rodrigues <rodrigc(a)crodrigues.org>
On Thu, May 26, 2022 at 4:56 PM Scott McCarty <smccarty(a)redhat.com> wrote:
> 1. Make RHEL available as a runner at GitHub. This would justify
investment in building #2
> 2. Create GitHub actions code for automation, which would live in the
containers (aka Podman) community
> 3. Perhaps productize these as some sort of RHEL/UBI content which
people could depend on Red Hat for. AKA, a productized version of #2.
Nalin has pointed out these GitHub Actions:
In the documentation for https://github.com/redhat-actions/podman-login
there is this:
*This action only runs on Linux, as it uses podman to perform the log in.*
*GitHub's Ubuntu action runners come with Podman preinstalled.*
*If you are not using those runners, you must first install Podman.*
So from reading this, my understanding is that:
1. GitHub Actions using podman and buildah do exist
2. These GitHub Actions run on existing Github Ubuntu action runners
3. These Actions are not dependent on RHEL
Is my understanding correct?
Podman mailing list -- podman(a)lists.podman.io
To unsubscribe send an email to podman-leave(a)lists.podman.io